Skip to content

Room101: Johnny Tobacconaut or Big Payback? A Complete Comparison

on

Room101 Cigars: Bold, Unique, Unforgettable

Room101 was started in 2009 by Matt Booth, a former Marine with a flair for design. He wanted to create cigars that stood out—both in flavor and in personality. The brand mixes a sense of fun with serious attention to quality, making cigars that feel memorable from the first draw.

Two of Room101’s most talked-about lines are the Johnny Tobacconaut and Big Payback. Both offer very different experiences, but each shows the brand’s signature style: bold flavors, interesting stories, and cigars that keep people coming back for more. In this blog, we’ll break down these two lines so you can see which one fits your taste.

Johnny Tobacconaut – A Celestial Journey

The Johnny Tobacconaut line is known for its playful theme and approachable flavor. All cigars in this line are produced in Nicaragua and feature an Ecuadorian Connecticut Shade wrapper, which gives them a smooth, medium-bodied profile.

Available Products:

Flavor Profile:

  • Initial Notes: Creamy vanilla, milk chocolate

  • Mid-Smoke: Light pepper, subtle floral undertones

  • Final Third: Smooth hints of butter and mild spice

  • Strength: Mild to medium

  • Body: Medium

Smoke Experience:

These cigars are consistent and easy to smoke, with a moderate draw and even burn. They are great for both casual and dedicated smokers who want a flavorful experience without overwhelming intensity.

Pairing & Occasion:

Pair with light rum, mild coffee, or a white wine. Perfect for morning or afternoon enjoyment.

Big Payback – Bold and Dynamic

The Big Payback line is heavier, designed for smokers who like a punchier, more full-bodied experience. Each variant highlights different aspects of tobacco, giving enthusiasts a wide range of flavor profiles to explore.

Available Products:

Flavor Profile by Variant:

  • Connecticut: Creamy, nutty notes with touches of cedar, hay, and subtle sweetness.

  • Maduro: Notes of cocoa, leather, earth, and a subtle sweetness, complemented by a smooth draw and even burn.

  • Nicaragua: Medium to full-bodied cigar that delivers a complex flavor profile, with notes of black pepper, toasted oak, baker's cocoa, and a hint of molasses sweetness.

  • 70: notes of earth, dark fruit, baking spice, and soft pepper. 

Smoke Experience:

These cigars offer dense smoke, consistent draw, and generally even burns. Some variants like the 70 are larger and take longer to smoke, making them ideal for relaxed sessions.

Pairing & Occasion:

Pair with aged bourbon, dark beer, or espresso. Best suited for evening enjoyment or after hearty meals

 

Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature

Johnny Tobacconaut

Big Payback

Wrapper

Ecuadorian Connecticut Shade

Varies (Maduro, Nicaragua, Connecticut)

Strength

Mild to Medium

Medium to Full

Flavor Profile

Creamy, vanilla, subtle spice

Bold, earthy, cocoa, pepper

Body

Medium

Full

Draw & Burn

Effortless, even

Open and consistent, sometimes slight waves

Smoke Duration

Medium-length

Medium to long (70 is longest)

Ideal Pairing

Light rum, mild coffee, white wine

Aged bourbon, espresso, dark beer

Best Occasion

Morning or afternoon

Evening or after hearty meals


Choosing Between Johnny Tobacconaut and Big Payback

  • Johnny Tobacconaut: Ideal for smokers who prefer a milder, creamy smoke with approachable flavors. Great for casual sessions or lighter moods.

  • Big Payback: Best for those seeking bolder, full-bodied experiences with complex flavors and longer sessions. Each variant offers a slightly different twist on intensity and profile.

Both lines highlight Room101’s creativity and variety. Exploring these two will give you a clear sense of what the brand can offer, whether you want a smooth, medium-bodied smoke or a bold, full-bodied adventure.

 

    Related Posts

    AJ Fernandez: The Modern Master of Nicaraguan Cigars
    December 09, 2025
    AJ Fernandez: The Modern Master of Nicaraguan Cigars

    A deep dive into New World Oscuro, Enclave Broadleaf, and San Lotano Connecticut If...

    Read More
    Caldwell & Room 101: Boutique Royalty
    December 09, 2025
    Caldwell & Room 101: Boutique Royalty

    When it comes to boutique cigars, few names spark more excitement and loyalty than Caldwell Cigars...

    Read More
    Drawer Title

    This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website.

    Welcome to Tinder Box

    Are You 21 or Older?

    This website sells tobacco products and is intended for adults only. Please confirm your age to continue.

    By entering, you confirm that you are of legal smoking age in your region.

    Come back when you're older

    Sorry, the content of this store can't be seen by a younger audience. Come back when you're older.

    Similar Products